auto dealers car dealers Cars Clean Transport CleanTechnica CleanTechnica Exclusive Consumer Technology Electric Cars Electric Vehicles Europe Europe EV sales EV sales EV Sales Forecasts Market Research Research Technology US EV sales

Why Europe Beats USA Again In Electric Car Sales

Why Europe Beats USA Again In Electric Car Sales


Revealed on January 1st, 2019 |
by Maarten Vinkhuyzen

January 1st, 2019 by Maarten Vinkhuyzen 

Because the years transition, lists of EVs coming to market in 2019 are omnipresent. However there’s a drawback with these lists. First, they’re primarily for the USA market, and second, the supply of these new fashions just isn’t nice — solely in California or a handful of “zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) states,” or another very restricted provide method.


The comprehensible response of many is that the carmakers aren’t inquisitive about bringing electrical automobiles to market, that these are solely “compliance cars” that they should promote in sure states. However manufacturers which have introduced a change to 100% battery electrical automobiles within the brief or mid time period, like Jaguar and Volvo, are very critical.

And types which have gone all-in, like Sensible and Polestar, don’t make compliance automobiles. They’re simply as dedicated as Tesla.

In 2012, the US electrical automotive market was the main market on the planet, because of the Chevy Volt, Nissan LEAF, Toyota Prius PHEV, Ford’s two Energi fashions, the Mitsubishi i-MiEV, and the Tesla Mannequin S, amongst others. In Europe, Norway and the Netherlands began formidable incentive packages. These have been later adopted by incentive packages in different European nations, much less formidable however providing EV drivers incentives nonetheless. In 2014, China began its electrification efforts. It used the “Let a Hundred Flowers Blossom” strategy to get speedy improvement of native manufacturing in an open and aggressive market.

After which one thing unusual occurred. Whereas the remainder of the world slowly began to develop its EV market, the US market received caught. In reality, 2015 gross sales have been even decrease than 2014 gross sales. In 2016, there was a market restoration, however outdoors Tesla, there was solely about 20% progress. Not very a lot for a younger market with this a lot promise for a fantastic future. Loren McDonald did write a fantastic article concerning the market push of latest fashions.

The article doesn’t clarify why the USA market is creating slower than the European or Chinese language markets, and why older fashions are doing nice in Europe.

The Chinese language used, like Norway, a mixture of monetary and non-financial incentives to push EV adoption, like parking permits and registration advantages. Mixed with the various native governments that hoped to push their champions to turn out to be the subsequent industrial big, the Chinese language EV market began to develop very quick.

Plug-in Car Sales

Yr USA Europe

Europe Share of Mixed Sales

2012 52,607 43,543 45% 2013 97,507 67,026 41% 2014 122,438 100,zero60 45% 2015 116,099 193,439 62% 2016 158,614 222,619 58% 2017 199,818 306,143 61% 2018 (Jan–Nov) 312,877 345,312 52%

Sources: InsideEVs & EV Sales Weblog

However the progress in Europe was extra natural. There have been many various incentive schemes, typically much less beneficiant than the US schemes, and badly publicized. Nonetheless, the European market overtook the US market and even the Mannequin three avalanche this yr couldn’t shut the hole.

In a earlier article, I speculated about non-US carmakers not exporting to the USA, that it was extra worthwhile to ship their merchandise to clients who had signed a gross sales order and positioned a deposit. Placing automobiles on a dusty parking zone at a supplier not likely fascinated with promoting them is a waste of assets. However the gross sales of regionally produced plug-ins just like the Chevy Bolt, Nissan LEAF, and Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid are additionally far decrease than could be anticipated.

In 2017, gross sales via sellers have been 150,000 within the USA and 280,000 in Europe. (I get these numbers by omitting the Tesla gross sales.) That is opposite to the assumption that carmakers are solely producing compliance automobiles. They’re principally the identical carmakers in Europe as within the USA that make and promote these EVs.

The large distinction is the gross sales channel. The favourite bogeyman of many a car-buyer story is the American auto vendor, who repeatedly fails to promote EVs. In Europe, most gross sales are by particular order. Ready three months for even a easy Renault Twingo or VW Golf is regular. In the USA, automobiles are purchased like denims at Walmart. The client expects to have a large selection and to go away the premises with the product of his selection in a single or two hours.

There are over four,000 Chevy sellers within the USA. In colours, trim ranges, and choices, there are lots of if not hundreds potential configurations for the Chevy Bolt. No supplier can ever have most configurations in inventory, solely a small sub-selection of hopefully the preferred fashions. This many sellers can solely have sufficient automobiles in inventory of merchandise that promote in excessive volumes.

The techniques employed by the Japanese and Koreans once they entered the USA automotive market many years in the past ought to be used once more for plug-in automobiles (PEVs). However the established dealerships of Chevy and Nissan haven’t any purpose to attempt to construct a PEV enterprise in that method, and GM and Nissan don’t push them to do it.

Higher markets elsewhere and merchandise which are onerous to promote can’t be the entire purpose why the hardest salesmen fail to promote electrical automobiles, although. In the event that they needed to promote them, they might promote them — however they don’t.

To elucidate this, I’ve a wild-ass guess (WAG), only a intestine feeling which may have some fact at its core. The slowdown of vendor gross sales began in 2014, when Tesla turned profitable and refused to promote via sellers. If sellers of their thoughts equated Tesla and PEVs as the identical factor, they could nicely have developed an aversion towards promoting PEVs. Then it in all probability went from “Tesla is the enemy” to “PEVs are the enemy.”

2019 Prediction

With this in thoughts, we will look in a totally totally different approach on the gross sales expectations for 2019.

I’ve made an inventory of most fashions which might be new (or refurbished sufficient to be engaging once more). Some have formally entered the market within the final month or few months. In actuality, 2019 is when gross sales start in earnest. Mini and VW have a little bit of a status utilizing sliding home windows of their planning. However it seems they’ve a minimum of began the preparations.

Model Mannequin Battery (kWh) Worth Audi e-Tron 95 $ 75,000 BMW i3 42 $ 45,000* Hyundai Kona EV 64 $ 38,000* Hyundai Ioniq EV 39 $ 34,000* Jaguar I-Tempo 90 $ 69,500 Kia e-Niro 39-64 $ 40,000* Kia Soul EV 39-64 $ 38,000* Mercedes EQC 80 $ 70,000* Mini Electric 42 $ 30,000* Nissan Leaf E-Plus 60 $ 35,000* Porsche Taycan 90 $ 90,000 VW ID Neo 48 $ 30,000*

*Costs are decided after in depth research utilizing tea leaves, totally different crystal balls, laying the tarot, and drawing every automotive’s horoscope. If at some future date a supplier (or, heaven forbid, a carmaker) decides to make use of a special worth, the celebs are at fault. You can’t maintain me accountable (I don’t know what that’s).

These are all fashions that may do very properly of their phase, if a critical effort is made to promote them. For the explanations mentioned above, I doubt that would be the case.

They’re all manufacturing constrained by their battery provide and overly cautious planning. Overstock is the nightmare of each manufacturing planner, they usually don’t but consider out there potential of those automobiles like we do.

My guess is they’ll all promote twice to 10 occasions as a lot in Europe as within the USA, even with the stiffer competitors of the automobiles that may enter the European market in addition to these fashions, automobiles proven within the subsequent desk.

Model Mannequin Battery Worth DS three Crossback E-Tense 50 € 35,000* Opel / Vauxhall Corsa 60 € 30,000* Peugeot 208 60 € 30,000* Peugeot 2008 60 € 35,000* Renault Zoe (subsequent gen) 50? € 27,000* Seat e-Mii 37 € 20,000* Skoda e-Citigo 37 € 19,000* Tesla Mannequin three 50-75 € 37,000–80,000* VW e-Up! 37 € 21,000*

Beside these automobiles I anticipate 1 or 2 surprises from Nissan and Renault. They’re within the behavior of beginning manufacturing earlier than they announce the automotive to the general public and have some SUV or CUV within the pipeline. Or maybe we’ll see an sudden providing from a Japanese or Chinese language carmaker.

The DS three and the Peugeot 2008 are direct rivals to the Kona EV and e-Niro. The opposite Europe-only automobiles are too small for the US market.

With these New Yr’s lists ought to return a prediction on gross sales and market progress. With all of those new entrants, 2019 can be a really fascinating yr, each within the USA and in Europe. My hope is the carmakers will shock us with a capability for high-volume manufacturing, that consumers have sufficient selection of fashions with respectable vary, charging velocity, and a helpful charging community.

I anticipate gross sales of 400,000 within the USA and 600,000 in Europe, and I hope I’m utterly fallacious, that the numbers shall be far larger. 

Help CleanTechnica’s work by turning into a Member, Supporter, or Ambassador.
Or you should purchase a cool t-shirt, cup, child outfit, bag, or hoodie or make a one-time donation on PayPal to help CleanTechnica’s work.

Tags: auto sellers, automotive sellers, Europe, Europe EV gross sales, EV gross sales, EV Sales Forecasts, US EV gross sales

Concerning the Writer

Maarten Vinkhuyzen Grumpy previous man. The most effective factor I did with my life was elevating two youngsters. Solely completed main schooling, however once you don’t go to high school, you’ve got plenty of time to learn. I switched from accounting to software program improvement and ended my profession as system integrator and architect. My 2007 boss received two electrical Lotus Elise automobiles to point out policymakers the longer term course of power and transportation. And I’ve been trying to exchange my diesel automobiles with electrical automobiles ever since.

(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); = id; js.src = “//”; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); (doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About the author