15 minutes of fame Andy Warhol Clean Power Clean Transport Electric Vehicles Elon Musk Green Economy investment Media Policy & Politics Solar Energy Technology Tesla twitter

The Ticket To Ride: Elon’s Tweets + Participatory Culture


Clear Energy
Elon's tweets

Revealed on October 21st, 2018 |
by Carolyn Fortuna

October 21st, 2018 by Carolyn Fortuna 

The current US Safety and Change Fee’s (SEC) censure of Tesla CEO Elon Musk resulting from his tweets factors out how far eliminated many US main establishments are from the truth of efficient modern communication.

Social media, with its potential for candid and fluid back-and-forth chats, can develop relationships in a extra pure, natural, and influential method than company communications traditionally have.

It additionally promotes and reinforces information and considerate dialogue, typically hastening essential social change.

Musk’s social media messaging is indicative of right now’s participatory attract, through which shoppers have an actual probability of grabbing Warhol’s 15 minutes of fame and by which firms can study and enhance.

Elon's tweets

Warhol’s epiphany into the post-modern particular person anticipated that, as cameras shrank and screens multiplied, the limitations to on a regular basis individuals’s fame can be decreased.

A person like Elon Musk, who possesses energy within the present second in addition to a eager imaginative and prescient of a sustainable world tomorrow, epitomizes social energy asymmetries the place the well-known work together with the acquainted.

Elon’s tweets, so far as we now have seen after a lot analysis, have by no means come throughout as fraudulent statements nor misrepresentations of fiscal standing.

But, the SEC has demanded that Tesla “put in place additional controls and procedures to oversee Musk’s communications.” Not solely are many people skeptical that Musk will adhere to the precise letters of the SEC deal, however it appears extremely apparent that the SEC has missed out on the large image of up to date social media advertising and has tried to stifle one thing it must be selling — transparency and communication between corporations and their shareholders and clients.

Interconnections between Tesla’s rise within the market and Musk’s tweets have by no means been a secret, because the SEC acknowledged in its settlement press launch (“despite notifying the market in 2013 that it intended to use Musk’s Twitter account as a means of announcing material information about Tesla and encouraging investors to review Musk’s tweets”). The particular argument that the SEC has made about one particular concept or risk for the corporate (claiming that there have been “false and misleading tweets about a potential transaction to take Tesla private”) appears contradictory to how Elon Musk makes use of Twitter and the way his followers perceive he makes use of it, which is to interact with shoppers and shareholders and thus present them with extra of a voice on substantial firm issues. Saying the thought on Twitter was a approach — probably the most logical approach — to particularly ask all shareholders for his or her perspective on that concept. Musk used the time period “considering” and stated in the long run that the choice to proceed or not was as much as shareholders. What extra might a shareholder need than to be concerned in such a momentous choice?

A Extra Even Market Enjoying Subject with Musk and Twitter?

“The future of advertising is the internet.”
— Invoice Gates

Tesla’s 2018 settlement with the SEC included an settlement that Musk wouldn’t tweet concerning the firm with out clearance from the corporate’s authorized workforce. (“Tesla will establish a new committee of independent directors and put in place additional controls and procedures to oversee Musk’s communications.”) For anybody who spends at the very least a small time every day on one of many many and evolving social media platforms, we all know that such an settlement — if it might truly be enacted — takes Musk’s voice and authenticity out of what has been lengthy understood as Tesla’s main technique of selling.

Tweeting is a part of the Tesla advertising palette that features YouTube as properly however not conventional promoting or Fb, however the Tesla shopper base intently watches and clings to Musk’s tweets, not Tesla’s YouTube channel and even its company Twitter channel. The authenticity and substantive info offered by Musk on Twitter is partly why he’s adopted 23 million customers on Twitter and the Tesla account is adopted by solely three million. Moreover, Musk is extra playful and downright humorous on his account, and in addition tweets about SpaceX, The Boring Firm, and AI. Moreover, he drops regular, human notes about the significance of innovation, notably with regard to Tesla. Ought to spur-of-the-moment feedback like that be slowed and stifled by a panel of tweet reviewers?

Since its rise to public recognition, Tesla has insisted that conventional print promoting simply isn’t the suitable match for the clear power and electrical automotive firm. The closest it acquired was a 2017 novice video advert contest advised by a 10-year-old, one thing Musk seemingly found by way of Twitter. Musk then introduced the competitors by way of Twitter and introduced the winner to his 11 million Twitter followers.

First! https://t.co/OXNEgDnhku

— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) July 29, 2017

The instruments and methods for speaking with clients have modified considerably with the emergence of social media. Fluid internet-based messages have turn out to be a significant factor in influencing numerous elements of shopper conduct — shopper consciousness, unfold of data, opinion molding, buy conduct, and post-purchase communication and analysis.

Musk’s early understanding of social media’s potential as a hybrid promotional combine created the very mentor-to-consumer conversations which the SEC has designated as problematic. Truthfully, although, Elon’s tweets are a signifier of the kinds of conversations that main firms the world over at the moment are incorporating to drive the marketplace. To stifle such a notable company consumer of Twitter is to stifle a shift to this extra fluid, open, public strategy to communications.

Musk’s Tweets Translate right into a Sort of Everyman Communication

“Many a small thing has been made large by the right kind of advertising.”
— Mark Twain

Wall Road Journal carried out an evaluation of Musk’s tweets from 2018 and prior, and though that exposé predated the SEC debacle, it does supply us some fascinating good insights into Musk’s tweets. His ubiquitous presence in social media on a regular basis life has largely been about persuading an viewers to “drink the Tesla Kool-Aid.” That ought to not have come as a shock to anybody, together with the SEC.

Nevertheless, he does so in a approach that’s extremely atypical of huge company CEOs — he replies quite a lot of the time to fellow tweeters. He isn’t solely blasting a message. There’s clearly mutual affect by way of the communication — a real forwards and backwards. Many shopper concepts are included into the merchandise, and it seems Musk needed to interact shareholder concepts in an identical method.

Elon's tweets

Graphic by way of WSJ

It will get much more fascinating.

Elon’s replies aren’t solely for big-named people with gigantic numbers of followers. Somewhat, they are typically directed extra to individuals who have fewer than 500 followers than those that have over 2000 followers! That makes Elon Musk a sort of everyman — in a way, he’s simply one other social media consumer who shares experiences, interpretations, and views. And that’s how he has defined he feels in sure circumstances, comparable to when he was defensively reacting to what he thought-about very deceptive and unjust criticisms of his efforts to assist others.

Musk validates members who use social media — individuals aiming to generate concepts about society’s sustainability issues and options, individuals aiming to enhance Tesla’s merchandise, and other people merely in search of some reference to one of the influential individuals in society, somebody who evokes them. His insistence on behaving as an everyman and never appearing as if he’s above the gang provides others the arrogance to aspire to the identical degree of success, realizing that he’s simply human as they’re.

Social co-production, by which people produce one thing collectively regardless of being miles aside, is the inspiration of social media. The SEC settlement alienates communicative co-production throughout courses and geography.

Elon's tweets

As a result of Musk’s Twitter tone is informal, he appears extra approachable and actual than different company CEOs. As early as 2006, Henry Jenkins coined the time period “participatory culture” to explain US teenagers who have been turning into media creators. Net 2.zero, because it has additionally been referred to as, reworked info dissemination and formalized digital applied sciences’ position in social persuasion. It designates the involvement of customers, audiences, shoppers, and followers within the creation of tradition and content material.

Elon Musk’s tweets have develop into greater than a give-and-take with followers and even include the occasional self-deprecating humor. Certainly, Jenkins‘ description of participatory tradition as having “relatively low barriers to artistic expression and civic engagement, strong support for creating and sharing creations, and some type of informal mentorship whereby experienced participants pass along knowledge to novices” is a eager rationalization of Musk’s relationship to his Twitter followers. He’s the skilled techno-geek participant who’s sharing his physics background and sustainability imaginative and prescient to lesser skilled people who, in flip, determine if and what sort of buy-in — whether or not monetary or philosophical — they may supply.

Wired correlated Musk’s Twitter exercise and Tesla’s tumultuous inventory worth, highlighting the moments the place the market’s analysis of the corporate’s value rose or fell based mostly on the CEO’s posts. Is that this fraud or finesse? A dialectic or disingenuous digital advertising?

Elon's tweets

Elon's tweets

Ultimate Ideas

“Advertising is the art of convincing people to
spend money they don’t have for something they don’t need.”
— Will Rogers

Elon Musk’s tweets as efficient local weather change infotainment and for-profit argumentation must be distinguished from out-and-out overt makes an attempt to unfairly manipulate the capitalist system.

Musk is an object lesson for the remainder of us concerning the revenue and persuasion inherent inside social media. As he’s in contrast to company CEOs in lots of different methods, Elon’s tweets, too, are uniquely Elon. Whereas most CEOs have an invisible infrastructure that designs media messages as rigorously managed speech, Musk is genuine, unpredictable, and consultant of our society as we speak. It is likely one of the issues his followers completely love about him and Tesla.

Social media provides a melting pot communicative trade, a disregard for conventional media measures, and a chance to make clear participatory tradition’s affect on social norms and markets. Let’s let Elon be Elon, we could? We’ll profit in the long term from his artwork and spontaneity.

Elon's tweets

Help CleanTechnica’s work by turning into a Member, Supporter, or Ambassador.
Or you should purchase a cool t-shirt, cup, child outfit, bag, or hoodie or make a one-time donation on PayPal.

Tags: 15 minutes of fame, Andy Warhol, Elon Musk, Tesla, twitter

Concerning the Writer

Carolyn Fortuna Carolyn Fortuna, Ph.D. is a author, researcher, and educator with a lifelong dedication to ecojustice. She’s gained awards from the Anti-Defamation League, The Worldwide Literacy Affiliation, and The Leavy Basis. She’s molds scholarship into digital media literacy and studying to unfold the phrase about sustainability points. Please comply with me on Twitter and Fb and Google+

(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1”; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); (doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About the author