Carbon Emissions Clean Power Clean Transport Climate Change electric car Electric Cars Electric Vehicles Elon Musk EV Fossil Fuels Renewable Energy Solar power Technology wind power

EVs Vs. Renewables — A Tale Of Two Revolutions

EVs Vs. Renewables -- A Tale Of Two Revolutions

Clear Energy


Revealed on October eighth, 2018 |
by Steve Hanley





October eighth, 2018 by Steve Hanley 


A decade in the past, renewable power and electrical automobiles have been for treehuggers. No utility firm worthy of the identify was contemplating vital investments in wind or solar energy. Grid-scale battery storage didn’t even exist. And few main automotive corporations have been providing EVs.

Renewables Win On Worth

At present, renewable power is sweeping apart coal, fuel, and nuclear within the power sector whereas electrical automobiles are nonetheless however a tiny fraction of latest automotive gross sales. Why? To paraphrase James Cargill, “It’s the money, stupid!” Over the previous decade, the price of renewables has fallen thus far, so quick, they’re merely the least costly choice for producing electrical energy.

Deloite renewables report

That time was pushed house lately by a report by Deloitte, an internationally acknowledged consulting agency. That report leads off with this assertion: “​Technological innovation, cost efficiencies, and increasing consumer demand are driving renewables — particularly wind and solar — to be preferred energy sources. We examine seven trends that are driving this transformation.”

The report is full of nice charts and deep insights and makes for very fascinating studying, however it comes down in the long run to the only most essential think about all human interactions — value. Electrical energy is electrical energy. There are not any manufacturers hooked up to it that cloud individuals’s considering, no BMW three Collection versus Tesla Mannequin three competitors. Whoever could make and ship electrons reliably on the lowest value wins. It’s so simple as that.

EVs Dropping The Pricing Battle

On the EV aspect of the image, the speedy drop in prices that has propelled renewables to the forefront of the utility business has merely not occurred. Electrical automobiles with sufficient vary to satisfy the wants of atypical drivers have been costly then and they’re nonetheless costly at present. Positive, the fee per kWh of batteries has declined, however the sticker worth for an electrical or perhaps a plug-in hybrid automotive outfitted the best way individuals need is $40,000 and up — means up in case you are speaking a few Tesla, Jaguar, Audi, or Mercedes.

One other massive report from a worldwide consulting agency — AlixPartners — places the problem of constructing electrical automobiles profitably in stark phrases, in response to Reuters. It calculates electrical automobiles nonetheless value 7,800 Euros extra to supply than typical automobiles. Plug-in hybrids value 5,000 extra Euros. Everybody who drives an electrical automotive likes electrical automobiles. In a current research carried out in the USA, AlixPartners discovered greater than 20% of Americas say they need to purchase a automotive with a plug — if they will afford one.

There’s a very detailed research by researchers at Munich Technical College revealed by ResearchGate entitled “An Overview of Costs for Vehicle Components, Fuels and Greenhouse Gas Emissions” that features a useful graphic describing what it prices to fabricate a automotive with an inner combustion engine and transmission versus a automotive with an electrical powertrain. Usually, the report says the elements that make an electrical automotive go value about twice as a lot because the elements that make a standard automotive go.

Cost of electric car components

And there’s the rub. Whipsawed by strain from Tesla and calls for for decrease emissions from regulators in most world markets (besides, in fact, within the US), auto makers are taking a look at promoting their electrical automobiles at or under value. You don’t should be John Maynard Keynes to know that mannequin is unsustainable. You possibly can’t purchase apples for 1 / 4, promote them 5 for greenback, and hope to make it up in quantity. Market share is good however income are what make the world go spherical.

“Industry players are sort of caught between a rock and a hard place,” Shiv Shivaraman of AlixPartners tells Inexperienced Automotive Studies. “If they don’t participate in some way in the ‘new mobility’ revolution that’s coming, they stand to lose out on what might be the biggest thing ever in this industry. If they do participate, as so many are, they have the chance of benefiting from first-mover advantages, but they also face the possibility of going broke in the process.” Carlos Tavares, CEO of PSA, tells Reuters. “What everyone needs to realize is that clean mobility is like organic food — it’s more expensive.”

It Will get Worse

The excellent news for renewable power is that it’s now value aggressive with different strategies of producing electrical energy even with out authorities subsidies. That’s not the case for electrical automobiles. To offset the upper costs of EVs, governments all over the world for years have provided beneficiant incentives to assist prime the pump. However the development for such incentives is on a downward slope. In lots of nations, the emphasis is shifting away from money incentives towards extra authorities mandates.

China is decreasing or eliminating its EV incentives in favor of a brand new quota system set to enter impact firstly of subsequent yr. The UK authorities has simply introduced it doesn’t have the cash to proceed funding its EV incentives program. It intends to reduce the sum of money it presents consumers of battery electrical automobiles and get rid of incentives for plug-in hybrid automobiles utterly. As well as, electrical automotive incentives will probably be restricted to automobiles with a sticker worth of lower than £60,000.

In the meantime, regulators within the EU are pushing forward with plans to additional tighten emissions requirements starting in 2021. The brand new commonplace will make it very troublesome for producers to promote diesel-powered automobiles in any respect. Whereas that’s truly excellent news for individuals, who should breath within the crud that spews out of the tailpipes of diesel automobiles, it’s terrible information for the hundreds of thousands of people that depend on the European automotive business for his or her jobs.

What we’ve is an ideal storm that’s threatening the very existence of the automotive business, which is investing nicely over $200 billion to develop electrical automotive know-how. In current weeks, prime executives at Mercedes, BMW, and Volkswagen have all issued warnings to their stockholders that they need to anticipate income at these corporations to take a beating within the close to time period.

It’s The Cash, Silly

Individuals who learn CleanTechnica are typically robust supporters of insurance policies that restrict carbon emissions. “Climate change” just isn’t a unclean phrase round right here as it’s in some elements of society. All of us are wishing and hoping for the electrical automotive revolution to collect steam and drive fossil gasoline corporations out of enterprise, however human nature doesn’t reply to needs and hopes. Economics could also be an abstruse area full of densely worded monographs on obscure subjects, however the core of economics is brutally easy. Individuals are likely to make decisions based mostly on value. In different phrases, “It’s the money, stupid!” How else are you able to clarify that completely dreadful cars just like the Yugo, the Hyundai Excel, and the automobiles from Daewoo truly bought fairly nicely at one time?

The EV revolution can’t anticipate to be propped up by governments perpetually. What the world wants is electrical automobiles which are worth aggressive with typical automobiles and it wants them now. EVs gained’t dominate the highways and byways till they will compete face to face with the competitors and win. In essence, when it comes time for us to open our wallets, we aren’t interested by melting ice caps or particulates within the environment. We’re targeted on one factor and one factor solely — how a lot is that this automotive going to value?

Finish Fossil Gasoline Subsidies

Whereas everyone seems to be banging their head towards a wall making an attempt to make electrical automobiles cheaper, a important issue will get continually missed. Fossil fuels take pleasure in an financial benefit that quantities to just about $5 trillion in direct and oblique subsidies worldwide yearly, based on the Worldwide Financial Fund. The issue, in purely financial phrases, is that fossil gasoline corporations pay nothing for the injury they do to individuals and the setting. That’s ridiculous, or course, nevertheless it’s true. Maybe the most effective rationalization of how this occurs was given by Elon Musk at a presentation in Paris in 2015. It’s value reposting it right here and each individual studying that is inspired to observe the video of his presentation. It’s a basic, one which ought to be watched repeatedly till the message will get indelibly etched into our brains.

Value Of Automobiles Versus Value Of Gasoline

The difficulty is just not the price of automobiles, it’s the price of gasoline. If the worth of a gallon of gasoline included the price of the injury accomplished by burning it — together with the worth of all wars fought to acquire it and the price of sustaining a army presence to ensure entry to it — the worth on the pump can be over $10 a gallon.

Are you able to think about how the competitors between typical automobiles and electrical automobiles would change if that have been the case? Individuals can be lining up outdoors dealerships at 6 o’clock within the morning pounding on the doorways and demanding they be allowed to purchase an electrical automotive. The changeover from molecules to electrons would take years, not many years.

Conservatives who favor market based mostly options would get their want — a degree enjoying area the place the market picks winners and losers, not governments. No extra debates about junk science or whether or not people can actually affect the setting. Set the principles of competitors pretty and let the market determine. What could possibly be easier than that?

Koch Brothers The Guardian

Credit score: The Guardian

Of course, those self same conservatives don’t actually need a degree enjoying subject. They like it when some firms are allowed to foist the price of cleansing up their waste merchandise off onto the shoulders of others. Run this proposal by the Heritage Basis, the US Chamber of Commerce, the American Enterprise Institute, the Federalist Society, or any one of many dozens of different strain teams funded by the Koch Brothers and take heed to the screams of protest.

The Hanley Plan

My proposal is straightforward. Overlook cap and commerce techniques, tax rebates, carbon taxes, and all these different convoluted schemes. Within the US, make the federal tax on all fossil fuels equal to $1 a gallon as of January 1, 2019. The cash would go right into a belief fund for use to restore America’s crumbling infrastructure and for no different objective. Ratchet it up by 50 cents a gallon yearly thereafter. Then stand again and let the financial crucial of the free market work its magic. The demand for electrical automobiles would quickly drive down their value because of economies of scale. Drawback solved in a single swell foop!

Observe: If drafted I’ll run and if elected I’ll serve. Oh, and also you’re welcome.


Help CleanTechnica’s work by turning into a Member, Supporter, or Ambassador.
Or you should purchase a cool t-shirt, cup, child outfit, bag, or hoodie or make a one-time donation on PayPal.





Tags: Carbon Emissions, electrical automotive, Elon Musk, EV, fossil fuels, Renewable Power, Solar energy, wind energy





Concerning the Writer

Steve Hanley Steve writes concerning the interface between know-how and sustainability from his house in Rhode Island and anyplace else the Singularity might take him. His muse is Charles Kuralt — “I see the road ahead is turning. I wonder what’s around the bend?”

You possibly can comply with him on Google + and on Twitter.









(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1”; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); (doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));