Cars Clean Transport CleanTechnica CleanTechnica Exclusive Consumer Technology Electric Cars Electric Vehicles Elon Musk New Street Research Pierre Ferragu Technology Tesla Tesla Model 3 Tesla Model 3 production

Correction: Tesla Nailed Original Model 3 Production Plan

Correction: Tesla Nailed Original Model 3 Production Plan


Revealed on December sixth, 2018 |
by Zachary Shahan

December sixth, 2018 by Zachary Shahan 

Hundreds or tens of hundreds of Tesla Model 3 consumers received their automobiles ahead of initially anticipated. Tesla did obtain its unique Model 3 manufacturing plan.

Deceptive analysts and media protection of Tesla continues. Some of the widespread incorrect or deceptive storylines relating to Tesla is an odd one. Sure, for a time period, the Tesla Model 3 manufacturing ramp was slower than Tesla had forecast in earlier quarters — “production hell” was extra hellish than CEO Elon Musk thought. There’s completely no disputing that.

Nevertheless, any time somebody says Tesla was late on its unique Model 3 manufacturing plan, I cringe a bit. Tesla truly nailed its unique plan for the Model 3, and that meant that tens of hundreds of consumers acquired their Model 3s ahead of initially anticipated. I’ll come again to the unique timeline in a second, however we should always undergo the brand new feedback first.

To be clear, the brand new feedback come from a Tesla bull, Pierre Ferragu of New Road Analysis. New Road Analysis has a worth goal of $530 on Tesla. His assertion this week (by way of Teslarati and Barron’s) was: “By shooting way too high, Tesla failed on its original plan, but achieved a world-class result. The next production sites will be much more efficient, and will ramp very rapidly.” Naturally, I agree with the perspective expressed on the finish, however noting that Tesla didn’t obtain its unique plan for the Model 3 is inaccurate nonetheless.

Fortunately, I’ve handled this situation earlier than, so I’ll primarily republish an article under that I initially revealed in March of this yr. First, nevertheless, the brief abstract factors are as follows: In 2013, Elon Musk forecasted that Model 3 manufacturing would begin no later than 2017 (observe that this was earlier than the automotive was even named “Model 3”). Production of the Model 3 started in the midst of 2017 and slowly ramped up. In late November 2014, even nearly all of surveyed CleanTechnica readers, who’re sometimes fairly bullish on Tesla, anticipated that Model 3 manufacturing wouldn’t start in 2017. That suggests that hundreds or tens of hundreds of Model 3 consumers obtained their automobiles before initially anticipated. In August 2015, Tesla reiterated that first deliveries of the Model 3 have been nonetheless anticipated in late 2017. It wasn’t actually till Model 3 manufacturing started that Tesla’s forecasts began operating into issues. Principally, ramping up manufacturing of the Model 3 was more durable than anticipated, however hitting Tesla’s a lot earlier forecasts was not.

Additionally value noting, the early 2014 plan for Gigafactory 1 was to succeed in battery manufacturing supporting 500,000 automobiles a yr by 2020. Tesla appears to be on monitor for that. Elon Musk additionally famous in 2014 that he anticipated Tesla’s battery prices would get right down to $100/kWh earlier than a decade was up, and this yr said on two events that Tesla would attain that battery worth by the top of this yr. Once more, it appears Tesla had no drawback hitting its early targets and forecasts.

The rest of this text — after a brief pitch to turn out to be a CleanTechnica supporter — is almost all of that March 2018 article famous above. Take pleasure in.

I feel it was April 2013 once we first obtained phrase that Tesla Model 3 manufacturing would in all probability begin in 2017. Nicely, we didn’t have a reputation for the automotive but, so we referred to as it “Tesla’s fourth production model.” Tesla CEO Elon Musk was apparently hoping for a 2016 launch, however quietly knew and informed himself 2017 was extra doubtless. His actual response to some questioning from Engadget on the matter: “Hopefully 2016, but I would say no later than 2017.”

In August 2013, we came upon the identify was in all probability going to be Tesla Model E. Tesla tried to trademark that identify to have some enjoyable with the spelling of its eventual car lineup (S-E-X-Y). Nevertheless, Ford had the trademark “Model E” and didn’t need to give it to Tesla, so Tesla later modified the identify to Tesla Model ☰ (aka Tesla Model 3).

What’s fascinating to me right here is that the assertion that the automotive can be in manufacturing by 2017 was correct regardless that that was lengthy earlier than the automotive was even named Model 3.

Moreover, for all of the hype of the Model 3 being delayed, look, manufacturing truly started on the Model 3 inside the timeframe Elon estimated approach again in 2013.

I feel the 2017 estimate was talked about by Elon once more within the following yr, however I’m not discovering any reference to that in our archives.

In late November 2014, I polled our readers concerning the 2017 manufacturing goal for the Tesla Model 3. The goal at the moment didn’t embrace any forecast for the variety of automobiles produced — simply that manufacturing on the Model 3 would begin by the top of 2017. The bulk (62.5%) of our Tesla fanatic/fanboy readership responded that they didn’t assume the Model 3 would arrive in 2017. (In case you missed it, the Model 3 did arrive in 2017.)

By the best way, in October or early November 2014, Jerome Guillen (then Tesla’s “Chief Designer,” now President, Automotive) said that Tesla was aiming to supply 500,000 automobiles/yr by 2020. Presumably, if individuals thought the Model 3 wouldn’t arrive on time, additionally they thought the 500,000 automobiles/yr by 2020 aim was unrealistic. However Tesla later moved up the 500,000-by-2020 objective to a aim of 500,000/yr by 2018 (in response to large shopper demand for the Model 3). Although this stretch aim proved inconceivable, the 500,000 automobiles/yr by 2020 aim nonetheless looks like a very good risk.

As a aspect notice: We heard rumor in June 2015 that the Model 3 would even have a variety of 250 miles per cost, not merely the promised 200 miles. That was an enormous rumor, and we weren’t positive whether or not to get excited or be skeptical. Because it seems, the bottom Model 3’s EPA-rated vary is 220 miles* and the long-range Model 3 has 310 miles of vary in accordance with the EPA. (*The actual-world vary is claimed to be notably larger.)

In August 2015, these have been a few of my notes from a Tesla quarterly shareholder report:

  • The Model 3 design will probably be revealed within the first quarter of 2016. (Woohoo!)
  • First deliveries are nonetheless anticipated in late 2017.
  • Principally, the 3 continues to be on schedule, however there’s not rather more to say at this level.
  • Tesla thinks it’s nonetheless on monitor for 500,000 automobiles a yr by 2020, and that it’d even transcend that. 500,000 is predicated on Fremont manufacturing unit manufacturing capability, however Tesla might localize manufacturing in some locations in 3–5 years. (I’m guessing Australia and China are into account.)

Once more, first deliveries did happen in 2017. Truly, first deliveries got here in the midst of 2017, not the top of 2017. Nevertheless, it’s true that first deliveries to non-staff clients got here in late 2017.

I might additionally word right here that Elon by no means claimed mass manufacturing would start proper off the bat. Anybody conversant in ramping up manufacturing of a brand new car would know that’s not how it might occur. Taking that under consideration, begin of manufacturing in the midst of 2017 and slowly ramping that up (with hiccups) by means of the top of 2017 and starting of 2018 was truly forward of the schedule we presumed again in 2015.

And, once more, for those who take a look at our 2014 ballot, even bullish Tesla followers largely didn’t anticipate Tesla to get the Model 3 into manufacturing in 2017. (Context, Watson, context.)

I’ve acquired one other “by the way” notice for you. In late 2015, Elon said: “And with the (Tesla) Model 3 and various iterations on that platform, I’m really confident that we can do, you know, another 300,000 or 400,000 cars per year.” That suggests that Elon thought annual demand and manufacturing of the Model 3 and Model Y would complete 300,000–400,000 models per yr (mixed).

The newest feedback from Mr. Musk on this matter (which, admittedly, aren’t tremendous current) are that he now expects demand for the Model 3 and Model Y to be roughly 500,000–1,000,000 models a yr every — which means 1-2 million models a yr mixed.

In different phrases, Elon’s 2015 timeline for the Model 3 turned out to be primarily correct however he was drastically underestimating demand in comparison with at this time’s expectations. (Sound acquainted?)

When did the mid-2017 begin of manufacturing goal first come into play? On Might four, 2016, Elon hesitantly shared the accelerated goal. You might inform earlier than he stated it that he didn’t actually need to share the dates, however my guess is he figured the phrase would get out anyway (or he was simply making an attempt too arduous to elucidate how the tofu is made). He unveiled that the official Tesla goal for begin of manufacturing was July 1, 2017. However he emphasised that the goal was for suppliers simply to attempt to get them to ship in an inexpensive timeframe. The reasonable goal for precise starting of manufacturing remained late in 2017.

Right here was my remaining abstract sentence on this again then: “So, taking into account the near-fact that some suppliers will be late and there could be tooling/ramp problems, Tesla expects to have the Tesla Model 3 in serious production by the end of 2017 … but the closer to July 2017, the better.”

Because it turned out, at first of 2017, every little thing appeared to truly be on schedule for begin of manufacturing in July 2017. It was surprising. Most individuals didn’t consider it. Hardcore critics nonetheless claimed Model 3 manufacturing wouldn’t begin till 2019 or 2020 or one thing like that.

No, quantity manufacturing didn’t begin in the summertime or ’17, however manufacturing of the Model 3 did certainly begin then. By that point, in fact, many skeptics, “very serious analysts,” and naysayers dropped their claims of Tesla being unable to supply the Model 3. They stopped stating with 100% certainty that it might be years earlier than the Model 3 went into manufacturing, if it ever did. They dropped their claims that there was no means Tesla would hit its focused “end of 2017” begin of manufacturing. Nope, the objective posts had moved.

And within the second half of 2017, it lastly occurred. Tesla lastly fell behind on a few of its said manufacturing targets for the Model 3. Bottlenecks with battery manufacturing particularly — which Elon Musk lately admitted was ironic and presumably resulting from misplaced complacency — slowed down Tesla’s Model 3 manufacturing ramp. Maybe different bottlenecks are at play as nicely, however we haven’t actually heard of anything. Anyhow, with even one crucial machine down and one piece of the automotive popping out slower than deliberate, Tesla has missed a couple of Model 3 manufacturing forecasts in current quarters. It’s not enjoyable. It’s yet one more signal that Tesla and Elon don’t defy the legal guidelines of this universe and are certainly fallible. However it’s additionally a bit excessive, short-sighted, and disingenuous to behave like Tesla is all the time late, solely late, and must discover a working watch.

In reality, the bottlenecks within the second half 2017 didn’t cease Tesla from reaching Model 3 manufacturing in 2017, because it has focused since 2013 or earlier. The bottlenecks have slowed down the manufacturing will increase Tesla was aiming to realize, however they’ve kind of left Tesla the place it was anticipating to be when it was forecasting the story again in 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016.

Elon will get slammed fairly regularly for being overly optimistic with timelines. Should you take a look at what he stated again in 2013 about Model 3 manufacturing starting no later than 2017, the person was correct. His estimate was on the mark. His timeline (not fairly his hopes, however his dedicated timeline) was proper on the mark.

Who trusted his timeline? Who anticipated he would truly get the Model 3 into manufacturing in 2017? Not many individuals. And positively not the individuals who stated Tesla would crash and burn in 2013, in 2014, in 2015, in 2016, and but once more in 2017.

When contemplating who’s extra correct with timelines, then, maybe it’s time to provide Elon a bit of extra props and rather less sass.

Associated: Tesla gross sales stories

Help CleanTechnica’s work by turning into a Member, Supporter, or Ambassador.
Or you should purchase a cool t-shirt, cup, child outfit, bag, or hoodie or make a one-time donation on PayPal to help CleanTechnica’s work.

Tags: Elon Musk, New Road Analysis, Pierre Ferragu, Tesla, Tesla Model 3, Tesla Model 3 manufacturing

Concerning the Writer

Zachary Shahan Zach is tryin’ to assist society assist itself (and different species). He spends most of his time right here on CleanTechnica as its director and chief editor. He is additionally the president of Necessary Media and the director/founding father of EV Obsession and Photo voltaic Love. Zach is acknowledged globally as an electrical car, photo voltaic power, and power storage skilled. He has introduced about cleantech at conferences in India, the UAE, Ukraine, Poland, Germany, the Netherlands, the USA, and Canada.

Zach has long-term investments in TSLA, FSLR, SPWR, SEDG, & ABB — after years of masking photo voltaic and EVs, he merely has loads of religion in these specific corporations and seems like they’re good cleantech corporations to spend money on. However he presents no skilled funding recommendation and would quite not be liable for you dropping cash, so do not bounce to conclusions.

(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); = id; js.src = “//”; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); (doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About the author